Stanford Law’s New Humanitarian Software Tackles Lifetime-and-Death Coverage Problems in Conflict Zones – SLS Information and Announcements

The interdisciplinary initiative—which grew out of a chance discussion at an SLS event—develops study-primarily based methods aimed at reducing struggling in war and other conflicts

When humanitarian personnel are killed or wounded in areas under siege like Syria, Ukraine, or Afghanistan, the devastation of armed conflict is introduced into especially sharp focus. For the previous two many years, Humanitarian Notification Systems (HNS) have permitted humanitarian employees and other civilians to transmit their place, by GPS, to warn warring get-togethers of their existence. The hope is that the combatants use the facts to stay away from, for example, bombing a Doctors With no Borders medical facility. 

But these current notification units, generally operated by the United Nations’ Office environment for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, are utilized in an advertisement hoc trend, set up on a one particular-off basis in response to a specific conflict. They are rife with worries, which includes inaccurate details entries, deficiency of transparent assistance about who can participate in the notification methods, and weaknesses in maintaining information of notifications. These troubles make effective coordination between humanitarians and the warring functions a problem.

That’s wherever Stanford Law School’s (SLS) new Stanford Humanitarian Method comes in.

The Stanford Humanitarian Application formally released in late 2022, but its two SLS alumni-founders have been operating quietly for two many years with a team that is employing a new technique to HNS. The shortly-to-be-examined prototype—designed by MIT’s Lincoln Laboratory and funded by the United States Company for Intercontinental Growth (USAID)—confronts the coverage and technological challenges inherent in existing notification systems. For illustration, the new program employs blockchain know-how to develop an immutable history of the notifications, a characteristic that has been missing in present units. 

Stanford Legislation Faculty Senior Lecturer Allen Weiner, JD ’89, and the Humanitarian Program’s founding govt director Bailey Ulbricht, JD ’22, alongside with a small crew of SLS university student investigate assistants, are acquiring authorized and coverage steerage to assist humanitarian businesses that may undertake the new HNS. Their steering also could assistance the operation of present methods. Ulbricht and Weiner are on the lookout at challenging inquiries these as who must be permitted to use the process, and what the readily available responses are under intercontinental regulation when a humanitarian crew that has sent a notification is even so attacked. They cannot resolve the issue of deliberate attacks on assist workers—which have been escalating according to info from USAID—but it’s an concern that keeps them up at night time and one particular that things into their research. 

Meanwhile, Weiner and Ulbricht are ramping up the 2nd of the program’s two technological innovation-targeted, inaugural assignments: an ambitious review of how to employ legislation and policy to beat the destructive effects of misinformation, disinformation, and hate speech on civilians in destinations of conflict about the world. 

An SLS Meet-and-Greet Sales opportunities to a New Program

The spark for the Stanford Humanitarian Program was ignited by a chance dialogue at an SLS party in 2019.  

“I went to an party for the duration of my 1L calendar year for learners to satisfy professors operating in the global legislation arena and started off talking to Allen, telling him about the get the job done I experienced carried out in Syria before regulation university and how I was hoping to inevitably do some thing in global humanitarian law with a serious-planet target that could truly effect lives,” said Ulbricht, who worked in many capacities with Syrian refugees prior to law college, including as the founder of the non-revenue Paper Airplanes that provides 1-on-one language and coding classes to refugees. “Allen ideal absent claimed he also was contemplating about worldwide humanitarian law assignments with practical relevance. I went to his office a handful of times afterwards to talk additional and that is when we commenced honing the plan of doing the job on the issue of health care services in Syria being attacked. It just grew from there.”

Weiner place it simply: “We preferred to do a little something that would make war … considerably less bad.”

Prior to returning to instruct at his law school alma mater in 2003, Weiner worked for the Business of the Authorized Adviser at the U.S. Section of Condition, advising diplomats and plan makers on intercontinental regulation concerns and representing the United States in advance of the International Legal Tribunal for the previous Yugoslavia, the Global Courtroom of Justice, and the Iran-United States Statements Tribunal. Weiner serves as director of the Stanford Program in Intercontinental and Comparative Regulation and director of the Stanford Heart on Worldwide Conflict and Negotiation.

Ulbricht said the option to co-guide the software straight away immediately after finishing her Stanford Regulation degree was “a desire come correct.” The system is strange in various respects, she extra.

“There are not a large amount of educational facilities centered on humanitarian crises, and specially on conflict spots,” Ulbricht stated. “There are centers undertaking some excellent function on worldwide human legal rights, but those that get the job done on humanitarian troubles ordinarily have more of a public well being viewpoint. We’re seeking to fill that hole, recognizing that there are distinctive difficulties communities deal with in conflict options and that, unfortunately, these options are not heading absent anytime quickly. Our latest assignments have this distinct emphasis on the consequences of technological innovation in these environments, something that is fairly strange. Also—and this is a little something I’m particularly passionate about—we’re developing and doing our function in collaboration with genuine-planet associates to ensure a immediate effects.  It’s one purpose our work item may possibly seem a bit distinctive from the typical analysis paper.”

One illustration is what they phone the Guidebook, a tutorial for humanitarians to help them address some of the policy and authorized troubles connected to HNS. The Guidebook addresses the typically-advanced plan inquiries these types of as: What selections are obtainable to humanitarians when their notified web sites are struck? Which warring functions need to obtain humanitarian area information submitted by humanitarians by the notification technique? Really should non-state-armed teams be allowed to participate? The purpose is to deliver a steering doc beneficial for humanitarians as they navigate these sophisticated selections.

Confronting Inflammatory Speech on Social Media 

While the Stanford Humanitarian Method is harnessing technological innovation as a drive for very good as part of its HNS initiative, it is at the identical time analyzing the most likely destructive side of technology, namely the energy of social media to unfold inflammatory speech in conflict zones.

For this challenge, which is still in the early stages, Ulbricht and Weiner have partnered with the Global Committee for the Pink Cross (ICRC) to research the in some cases-lethal results of misinformation, disinformation, and hate speech on civilians in conflict settings. Using a series of circumstance studies, the venture will check out how inflammatory social media rhetoric can guide to violence from civilian populations–and what should really be performed to counter that violence. Finally, Ulbricht and Weiner approach to build plan, lawful, and operational recommendations that would support humanitarian businesses these as the ICRC and affect governing administration and social media businesses to superior secure civilians.

Weiner cites the coordinated disinformation marketing campaign versus civilians and humanitarian organizations in opposition-held territory in Syria as an case in point of the difficulty they are confronting.

“A citizen photographer named Mahmoud Reslan, who snapped a photo that went viral of a baby protected in blood following his house experienced been bombed, became the focus on of conspiracy theory and demise threats, as did Bana al-Abed, a kid who famously documented her expertise dwelling beneath siege in Aleppo on YouTube and Twitter,” Weiner explained. “Disinformation strategies aligned with the Assad routine also qualified the truth-finding mission of the Group for the Prohibition on Chemical Weapons. These strategies endanger civilians and humanitarian actors by accusing non-combatants of staying aligned with terrorists, on the exact same facet as the ‘enemy’ and hence not entitled to civilian defense.”

Weiner mentioned social media companies have written content moderation insurance policies created to cut down or take out data that incites violence, “but what we are interested in is how the examination should be different—and possibly a lot more vigorous—in cases of armed conflict,” Weiner continued. “The hope is that our exploration will catalyze the social media organizations to change their material moderation guidelines to get account of the specific situation of armed conflict and minimize the existence of material on their platforms that leads to these sorts of harms.” 

“The function of the program has this solid community fascination bent, focused on improving people’s life who are trapped in these horrible conflict circumstances,” Ulbricht mentioned. “International conflicts have the curse of often currently being so big, with so lots of big gamers, that it can be tricky to really have tangible impacts. And which is what we’re hoping to do.”

About Stanford Legislation School

Stanford Law School is a single of the nation’s foremost institutions for legal scholarship and instruction. Its alumni are among the the most influential conclusion makers in law, politics, small business, and high know-how. School members argue just before the Supreme Court, testify just before Congress, generate excellent authorized scholarship and empirical assessment, and lead often to the nation’s press as authorized and coverage gurus. Stanford Law University has recognized a design for authorized education that offers demanding interdisciplinary education, fingers-on working experience, international perspective, and focus on public assistance, spearheading a motion for transform.